==== Question 1: ==== * Does "Node Ordering Constraint" bug reported in paper works for more than 3 nodes? * Answer: Maybe, but this particular scenario does not work for **large** rings. * Description: This figure show the scenario of that bug which is described in paper: {{crystalball:chord-ordering-1.gif?600|Chord ordering bug}} * However, as described in the bellow figure, it requires that a new successor of $y$ (i.e. $z$) to be in predecessor neighborhood of $x$ which implies a small ring. {{crystalball:chord_orderong_samll_ring.gif?600|Chord ordering bug}} ==== Question 2: ==== * How long does it take to find ordering bug by exhaustive search in MaceMC, given only 3 node are running? * Answer: 7 Hours at depth 16 * This is the log file: [[Chord-Q2-LogFile]] ==== Question 3: ==== * What is the happening rate of Chord bugs? * Answer: 37 ordering bug is reported during 62100s for 25 nodes. * Notice that modelchecker was runnning per 80 minues, so the actual number of bugs should be like 1000